Should you ever argue with me

Writer's Journal

If you ever have the sweet joy of arguing with me on some topic, whether in person or online, you may find that I will argue strongly against you, perhaps even aggressively. Furthermore, should I give you the impression that I think you are foolish or ignorant, just know that unless I say so explicitly (which I think seldom happens), I am just arguing against your argument. I am not saying anything about you.

Unlike many people I have met, I separate person from argument. If I say your argument is fallacious, I mean your argument is based on incorrect reasoning. I am not saying you are stupid. Sometimes brilliant people make fallacious statements. It can happen.

I just want you to know because several times in the past I have found that people think that I am insulting them when I proceed to directly attack arguments I believe are based on poor reasoning or fallacious arguments. It is nothing personal. I just feel strongly about saying only things that are true or provable, and I expect this from others, not just myself.

So if you ever debate me and I think you have made a false claim, I will likely be direct about it, telling you that you are wrong and (most importantly) why you are wrong. I do not resort to name calling or attacks on the person. I attack the argument—sometimes raptorially.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *